Baking Plain City's favorite freshly made thin-crust square-cut pizzas, toasted specialty subs, and premium Italian dinners. Six decades of quality ingredients, local charm, and full-flavored family tradition.
Under New Ownership
Jan & Tony's Pizza is proud to announce we are officially under new local ownership! We are honoring 60 years of Plain City tradition with the exact same legendary thin-crust recipes, while bringing fresh energy, upgraded service, and premium quality to every single order.
Prepared from scratch every morning, hand-stretched for the perfect crust texture.
Premium Mozzarella shredded fresh in-house daily for the ultimate gooey melt.
Sourcing fresh meats and vegetables from local Ohio farms whenever possible.
Since 1966, Jan & Tony's Pizza has been a local tradition in Plain City, Ohio. For sixty years, we have baked our freshly made pizzas, baked Italian subs, and pasta dinners for local families using the same dedication and quality ingredients.
Whether you've been visiting us at our original red wood storefront for decades, or you are joining us for the first time at our modern location, we welcome you to share in our family's rich culinary history.
Best Seller
This is the King of pizzas and will fill you up! Add ground beef, ham, olives, and anchovies (on request) to our Deluxe pizza.
Craft Sub
Loaded with layers of thinly sliced ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni, melted provolone cheese, fresh shredded lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, banana peppers, and Italian dressing.
Classic Dinner
A delicious homemade twist on a classic favorite—perfectly cooked spaghetti tossed in a rich, flavorful tomato sauce and loaded with fresh vegetables, herbs, and generous toppings. Comes with 2 Meatballs and Breadsticks. Comforting, hearty, and packed with homemade goodness in every bite.
Loaded with premium ingredients & baked on traditional deck ovens.
Collect a Lucky Draw Raffle ticket with your purchase for a chance to win a FREE Medium Pizza or a FREE Sub!
Receive a Lucky Draw Raffle ticket automatically with every purchase.
We draw one lucky winner every single day from active orders.
Winners contacted by Phone / Text the very next day.
Treat your family to the best flavors in Jerome Village & Plain City. Whether you are grabbing a quick lunch, picking up dinner after a busy day, or catering a party, we have deals to satisfy every appetite.
Explore All SpecialsLunch specials starting at just $8.49 (Mon–Fri 11 AM – 2 PM).
Bundled pizza, subs, and drinks for the ultimate feast.
Complete your meal with crispy fries, pickles, or a fresh chef salad.
Order online via ToastTab and pick up fresh and piping hot.
Tue–Thu: 11 AM – 9 PM | Fri–Sat: 11 AM – 10 PM
Sun–Mon: 4 PM – 9 PM
